Written by: Mustafa Roker
The encounter between Imām Mohammed al-Bāqir AS and Mohammed b. al-Munkadir al-Taymī appears at least five times in the corpus of Fatimid literary heritage. Al-Dāʿī al-Ajal al-Fāṭimī Syedna al-Qāḍī al-Nuʿmān RA recounts it in his legal compendium, Kitāb Mukhtasar al-Athār, where he places it under the section Dhikr Ibtighāʾ al-Rizq wa-l-Amr bi-l-Ijmāl fī Ṭalabihi. His purpose there is twofold: first, to emphasise the fundamental necessity of ṭalab and striving for sustenance, and second, to stress that one should actively seek a livelihood through ḥalāl means. Such seemingly mundane activity is often shunned as profane. However, when undertaken within the framework of Sharīʿat, it becomes an act of worship. Thus, Sharīʿat transforms and elevates an ordinary pursuit into an act of devotion to Allah, thereby both improving and enriching one’s worldly life, and fulfilling the divine commandment:
وَمَا خَلَقْتُ الْجِنَّ وَالْإِنسَ إِلَّا لِيَعْبُدُونِ
I have not created jinn and mankind except to worship Me. (Q51:56)
The encounter appears at least four more times in historio-biographical chronicles. It is recounted in the 13th volume of Kitāb Sharḥ al-Akhbār and in the 4th volume of Kitāb ʿUyūn al-Akhbār, both featuring the narrative within their respective biographical entries on Imām Mohammed al-Bāqir AS. In composing his biographical account, Al-Dāʿī al-Ajal al-Fāṭimī Syedna Idris Imad al Din RA draws from the same collection of traditions preserved by Syedna al-Qāḍī al-Nuʿmān RA in Kitāb Sharḥ al-Akhbār, which chronicles the Imām ’s virtues. However, in Kitāb ʿUyūn al-Akhbār, he reorganises the material, changing its sequence to present a more thematic structure. The thematic structure organises the Imām’s different virtues, such as knowledge and munificence. It provides a set of narratives on each without explicitly naming the trait. This interventional approach underscores his editorial prowess and sophisticated historiographical style, particularly in his shaping of the source material.
A subtle yet notable distinction appears between the versions of Kitāb Sharḥ al-Akhbār and Kitāb ʿUyūn al-Akhbār, on one side, and the Kitāb Mukhtasar al-Athār, on the other. In the former two, Ibn al-Munkadir begins his narration with an introductory confession. In these accounts, he states: ‘I never believed that I would ever encounter someone like ʿAlī b. al-Ḥusayn (Imām ʿAlī Zayn al-ʿĀbidīn AS) again after his sorrowful demise (due to his exceptional merit and virtue) until I met his beloved son, Imām Mohammed al-Bāqir AS. Once, I tried to offer him advice but ultimately found myself learning from him and being counselled instead.’
He then proceeds to recount how he encountered the Imām returning from his estate under the scorching midday heat. Moved by what he perceived as unseemly behaviour for someone of the Imām 's stature, he felt compelled to counsel him against engaging in such worldly pursuits, citing the Imām 's elevated and venerable position within the Quraysh tribe and their esteemed status within the broader Muslim community. In response, the Imām clarified that his actions represented genuine devotion and submission to Allah's will. He explained that Islam explicitly commands believers to strive for their sustenance, making such efforts themselves acts of worship. Imām further went on to state that should Allah decree his death at that very moment, he would embrace it willingly, knowing he was engaged in divine obedience—for one should only fear death when acting contrary to Allah's commandments. Overwhelmed at this profound and erudite response, Ibn al-Munkadir conceded to the Imām's spiritual superiority and acknowledged both his elevated station and the wisdom of his counsel.
Ibn al-Munkadir’s prefatory remark, as preserved in the biographical literature, proves revealing. It highlights the concept of Tasalsul (succession), which features so prominently in the Fatimid Philosophy of History. The interjection is not merely a narrative variation; it carries greater import. It signifies that upon the demise of the Ṣāḥib al-Ḥaqq, his successor not only inherits his position and continues the chain of succession, but also becomes a living embodiment of his predecessor’s virtues and qualities. In this theological understanding, the deceased continues to exist through his successor, ensuring the unbroken transmission of divine guidance.
In this narration, Ibn al-Munkadir's internal commentary upon witnessing the Imām 's return from his estate raises several compelling questions. His recorded thoughts reveal an initial judgment, as explicitly detailed in the narrative: Upon observing a nobleman of the Quraysh in such a state, exerting himself at that harsh hour for material gain, he resolved, ‘I surely must counsel him and set him straight.’ Such a specific reaction invites an examination of multiple aspects of this encounter.
First, what was Ibn al-Munkadir’s social standing and position? What motivated his perceived need to counsel the Imām, and why did he initially consider such behaviour unbecoming? Second, why did he specifically invoke the notion of Qurashī nobility and emphasise tribal affiliations within this particular context? Finally, what does the Imām ’s brief, yet profound answer reveal about the socio-historical dynamics and realities of his time?
Addressing these questions necessitates exploring the life of Ibn al-Munkadir and his social milieu. Such an investigation can illuminate why he perceived the Imām ’s actions as needing correction, and why he framed his counsel in terms of lineage and status. Through this contextual analysis, one can better appreciate the complex social and historical currents embedded within this seemingly simple encounter between two figures of early Islamic history.
Brief note on sources
Islamic biographical dictionaries represent an offshoot of prosopographical literature (ṭabaqāt). These works offer invaluable insights into the lives of eminent figures of each historical era. In examining Ibn al-Munkadir’s life, Shams al-Dīn al-Dhahabī’s (d. 748/1348) extensive biographical work Siyar Aʿlām al-Nubalāʾ provides a detailed portrayal of his character and achievements. Another significant aspect of his biography appears in Abū Nuʿaym al-Iṣfahānī's (d. 430/1038) hagiographical dictionary Ḥilyat al-Awliyāʾ wa-Ṭabaqāt al-Aṣfiyāʾ. Although Abū Nuʿaym works with many of the same traditions that al-Dhahabī later incorporated, he arranges his material differently. His presentation creates an intersection between ḥadīth scholarship and the Sufi current in Islam. This arrangement reveals the ascetic mindset of his biographical subjects, pious traditionalists such as Ibn al-Munkadir.
Furthermore, secondary sources such as Shawqī Ḍayf’s Tārīkh al-Adab al-ʿArabī, Marshall Hodgson’s The Venture of Islam, and G. R. Hawting’s study on the Umayyads as the First Dynasty of Islam provide valuable details regarding the Medinan social environment and the prestige and elevated status that the clan of Quraysh commanded during the Umayyad era. Such contextual knowledge enriches our understanding of this meeting and situates Ibn al-Munkadir’s remarks and actions.
Mohammed b. al-Munkadir: his life and his times
Mohammed b. al-Munkadir b. ʿAbd Allāh b. al-Ḥudayr b. ʿAbd al-ʿUzzā b. ʿĀmir b. al-Ḥārith b. Ḥāritha b. Saʿd b. Taym b. Murra b. Kaʿb b. Luʾayy was born in Medina and belonged to the Taym clan, itself a branch of the larger Quraysh tribe. Al-Dhahabī accords him considerable prestige, describing him as an Imām, a Ḥāfiẓ, and an exemplary figure of his generation.
Born around the year 30 Hijri (approximately 650 CE), Ibn al-Munkadir belonged to the generation of the Tābiʿīn—those who had encountered the Companions of the Prophet. Given his birth date, he would have been of advanced age during his encounters with Imām Bāqir AS, which may have influenced his approach to offering counsel. He notably received, preserved, and transmitted Hadith on the authority of several prominent Companions, including Maulana Salmān al-Fārsī, Asmāʾ bint ʿUmays, Maulana Jābir, and Moulana ʿAbd Allāh b. ʿAbbās, ʿAbd Allāh b. ʿUmar, ʿĀʾisha, and several others. His comment, ‘I never believed that I would ever meet someone like ʿAlī b. al-Ḥusayn’, suggests that he may have also transmitted narrations on the authority of Imām ʿAlī Zayn al-ʿĀbidīn AS.
Al-Dhahabī proceeds to enumerate an extensive list of scholars who subsequently narrated traditions on Ibn al-Munkadir's authority, utilising him as a crucial link in their chains of transmission (isnad). Among these transmitters, Al-Dhahabī significantly notes the name of Imām Jaʿfar al-Ṣādiq AS. This observation proves particularly intriguing, as Shīʿī tradition records this encounter between Imām al-Bāqir AS and Ibn al-Munkadir through the authority of Imām al-Ṣādiq, which may have led Al-Dhahabī to establish this connection. Notably, however, both Kitāb Sharḥ al-Akhbār and Kitāb ʿUyūn al-Akhbār conspicuously omit any specific transmitting authority for this encounter. Among other distinguished scholars who reported Hadith on his authority, Al-Dhahabī mentions al-Zuhrī, Hishām ibn ʿUrwa, and Sufyān al-Thawrī.
By all accounts, Ibn al-Munkadir emerges as a figure of exceptional piety in early Islamic history. Al-Dhahabī provides an elaborate account of both his virtues and those of his father. Belonging to the al-Taym clan, his father was ʿĀʾisha’s maternal uncle and maintained close ties with her. On one occasion, during a period of severe financial hardship, he approached her seeking assistance, and she promised that whenever grants came to her, she would first prioritise his needs. That very evening, as fate would have it, she received 10,000 dirhams as her share of the designated grant. Upon witnessing this sudden wealth, she exclaimed to herself, ‘O ʿĀʾisha, how swiftly Allah has tested you.’ She then dispatched the entire sum to al-Munkadir. With this sum, he purchased a concubine who subsequently bore him sons: Mohammed and his brothers Abu Bakr and Umar.
Further elaborating on his merits, al-Dhahabī notes that Ibn al-Munkadir was known as the leader of the Qur’an reciters (Sayyid al-Qurrāʾ) in the scholarly circles. He was renowned for weeping profusely during Qur'anic recitation, overwhelmed by the divine warnings and sacred signs contained within the divine text. Even Mālik b. Anas is reported to have attested that he was a leader among those who recited the Qur’an. His other notable virtues included remarkable generosity, shown in his frequent hosting and feeding of others; profound respect and veneration for his mother; unwavering piety; and his determined efforts to perform Hajj to Bayt Allah, even during periods of prolonged poverty. When questioned about undertaking such difficulty, given his impoverished circumstances, he replied with profound faith: ‘Hajj will take care of my debts.’ He also included his children in several of his pilgrimages, declaring, ‘I do so to present them before Allah.’
A certain ʿAbd al-ʿAzīz b. Yaʿqūb al-Majshūn reported that his father used to say, ‘Whenever I see Ibn al-Munkadir, I benefit in my religion’. Al-Dhahabī concludes his biographical entry by recording several miraculous karāmāt attributed to Ibn al-Munkadir, describing how his supplications to Allah were answered instantaneously, granting both him and those around him their desired material outcomes. He also records several pious counsels and wisdom attributed to Ibn al-Munkadir. Concerning his death, Al-Dhahabī notes that Ibn al-Munkadir passed away around 130 Hijri, having lived nearly a century. His scholarly legacy endures through an impressive corpus of hadith transmitted on his authority, numbering more than two hundred narrations.
From his biographical portrait, one can discern that Ibn al-Munkadir was renowned for his exceptional piety, deliberate detachment from worldly affairs, and widespread recognition among his contemporaries for his wisdom and spiritual counsel. These traits collectively suggest that he considered himself both capable and entitled to advise Imām al-Bāqir AS upon encountering him and witnessing what he perceived as inappropriate conduct. Al-Majshūn's testimony that he ‘benefited in his religion’ whenever he sought out Ibn al-Munkadir further attests to the authority and weight of his counsel.
The recorded examples of his pious counsels and attributed sayings further illustrate why he would have deemed the Imām 's industrious activities unbecoming. It should be remembered that his own familial circumstances were marked by poverty, a condition not uncommon among the pious and indeed regarded as praiseworthy and meritorious in early Islamic society. One of his counsels captures this ethic:
كم من عين ساهرة في رزقي في ظلمات البر والبحر
Several watchful eyes are devoted to providing for my sustenance in the darkness of land and sea.
Through this statement, he conveyed that divine providence renders conscious anxiety about sustenance unnecessary; rather, one should place complete trust in Allah and His divine decree, for He unfailingly provides for His creation. This counsel moved him so deeply that he would weep profusely, rubbing his tears on his face upon reciting it. Such instances illuminate his fundamental attitude toward material pursuits. He lived his life with deliberate modesty, relying entirely on faith as his guiding principle for sustenance. In one instance, during one of his pilgrimages, he distributed everything he possessed as charity (ṣadaqah), leaving himself with nothing but the clothes on his back. Subsequently, one of his followers, Mohammed ibn Hisham, assisted him with four thousand dirhams to complete his journey and meet his needs.
Within this historical and social backdrop, it would be natural that someone of Ibn al-Munkadir's temperament and convictions would view the Imām ’s worldly engagement in an unflattering light and with a hint of disapproval. Despite his illustrious lineage and profound knowledge, Ibn al-Munkadir perceived his laborious work under the scorching heat as conduct unworthy of pursuit. From his perspective, he sought to counsel the Imām AS based on the principle that Allah will provide sustenance even without such demanding undertakings on one's part.
Another one of Ibn al-Munkadir's counsels, however, presents an alternative perspective that would appear to vindicate the Imām 's endeavours even according to his own theological leanings. He also frequently declared:
نعم العون على تقوى الله الغنى
‘Indeed, the best assistance for observing Allah's Taqwa is material prosperity’.
Through this statement, he explicitly acknowledges that wealth and affluence indeed aid and facilitate one's observance of Islamic tenets and religious obligations. By his own admission, then, the Imām ’s act was not merely a worldly pursuit but, as Imām AS himself explained, it was out of devotion to Allah. His statements create a fascinating paradox: while he intellectually recognised the pragmatic utility of wealth, he personally chose an ascetic lifestyle, privileging his impoverished condition over material abundance and advocating for others to follow the same path.
These seemingly contradictory statements and biographical episodes from Ibn al-Munkadir's life reveal the complexity of his spiritual worldview. They provide important insight into his compulsion to counsel Imām Bāqir AS despite the inherent contradiction in his position. His advanced age, established reputation for pious counsels, and widely recognised ascetic credentials gave him the confidence to believe he was qualified to offer guidance to the Imām. Moreover, he harboured the reasonable expectation that someone of the Imām 's distinguished stature would give serious consideration to his spiritual counsel, even though his own theological framework ultimately supported the very actions he sought to criticise.
Qurashī dominance during the Early Islamic period and the reign of Banu Umayya
Ibn al-Munkadir belonged to the clan Banū Taym and was of Qurashī origin. This background makes his remark, ‘شيخ من اشياخ قريش’, more meaningful when he witnessed Imām Bāqir AS. He naturally would not have expected someone of such distinguished lineage to engage in what he considered inappropriate conduct. However, to situate his perspective, it is necessary to examine the social status of Quraysh during the early Islamic and Umayyad periods, when this encounter most likely took place.
Secondary sources make clear that Quraysh held a privileged status in the early Islamic period, with many scholars emphasising the tribe’s prestige. This distinction stemmed from their being the tribe of Rasūl Allāh SAW. For most Muslims, they were the only group eligible to assume the mantle of khilāfah or leadership in the Muslim community. Early Muslim leadership following the death of the Prophet SAW consisted solely of members of the Quraysh. This exclusivity was based on the early principle established during the succession dispute that ‘the Imāmat will remain in Quraysh.’ Similarly, the senior military command during the Early Islamic Conquests was with the Quraysh of Mecca. Following the earlier caliphate, Banū Umayya, upon their ascension, were themselves part of Quraysh. The same applied to the later Banū ʿAbbās. Both dynasties assumed power on the same theological foundation: the inherent primacy of Quraysh.
Similarly, all significant antagonistic powers that challenged Umayyad or Abbasid rule were also Qurashīs. Hawting makes a particularly sharp observation regarding ʿAbdullāh ibn al-Zubayr, who posed a major challenge to the Umayyads through his attempt to establish an alternative caliphate: since Ibn al-Zubayr had not espoused any particular doctrinal belief or become associated with any sect, his success in overthrowing the Umayyads would have merely constituted a transfer from one Qurashī caliphate to another. This observation demonstrates the predominance and political prominence of Quraysh throughout the early Islamic period. The extent of their power was such that other tribes came to view Quraysh as having sidelined them from the political stage, consequently harbouring deep resentment against their privileged position.
During the Umayyad period, Quraysh retained its elitist position despite the turbulence of ongoing tribal conflicts that characterised the Umayyad rule. Muʿāwiya and subsequent Umayyad rulers came to own extensive estates in the Ḥijāz, thereby reinforcing their lineage and ties with Quraysh’s native locality. Historical sources note that whenever there was any danger of a province rebelling against its governor, a Qurashī governor was ordinarily appointed, whose prestige and authority often sufficed to restore order. Furthermore, there was a marked tendency among the Sufyānid caliphs to select amīrs from tribes like Quraysh and Thaqīf, which carried a certain prominence and weight among the Arabs. Quraysh thus played a vital role in organising the empire both politically and administratively. Beyond political appointments, Quraysh also benefited materially: the Umayyads continued the established practice of distributing grants and stipends, often directing substantial shares to Qurashī notables. These allocations were not merely acts of generosity but calculated strategies to secure the loyalty of Quraysh’s aristocracy and prevent them from mobilising against Umayyad power. Thus, Quraysh was not only dominant on the political stage but also consolidated its wealth and influence, particularly in the Ḥijāz, emerging as a central pillar of both Umayyad politics and the socio-economic order.
Against this backdrop, the encounter between Imām al-Bāqir and Ibn al-Munkadir gains sharper meaning. The weight of Quraysh’s elite image would have framed expectations of how its members should conduct themselves. In this context, Ibn al-Munkadir’s retort becomes clearer. He invoked Quraysh’s privileged lineage and resented that someone of the Imām ’s stature would engage in tasks considered menial, acts he viewed as more fitting for the non-elite. However, it must also be noted that neither Imām al-Bāqir AS nor Ibn al-Munkadir, both residing in Medina, seemed to enjoy these governmental privileges. Regardless, the tribe’s overarching status persisted and was acknowledged throughout the Muslim world.
Medina as the centre of Piety-minded opposition
Another factor that may add yet another layer of perspective to this encounter lies in the broader social and regional dynamics of the time. After Medina lost its political prestige and was supplanted by Damascus as the Umayyad capital, it became the centre of what modern scholarship describes as a form of ‘piety-minded opposition’ to the Umayyads. Since the later years of ʿUthmān’s rule, Medina had fostered resistance to perceived unjust policies and nurtured a desire to restore the Islamic ideals of its early polity and social equality. With the rise of Umayyad rule, an entire generation came to see themselves as heirs of those traditions and values.
For many of these figures, political resistance had already proven futile, especially after the failed revolt of Ibn al-Zubayr. Their hopes for Medina's political centrality were dashed, as power had already shifted decisively to other centres such as Damascus and Kufa. Consequently, ‘ideal Islam’ became detached from political power and instead took shape in religious and scholarly circles. From this environment emerged a class of scholars (ʿulamāʾ) who sought to make Islamic norms and practices the true standard of Muslim life. In contrast, the Umayyads, immersed in empire-building and worldly luxury, were often seen as irreligious and detached from authentic piety. This opposition expressed itself through asceticism, devotion to the Qur'an, and the collection and teaching of ḥadīth, with Medina serving as the chief locus of this religious identity. Although the notion of a ‘piety-minded opposition’ has been critiqued by modern Islamicists, it provides useful context for Ibn al-Munkadir’s remark and his apparent undervaluing of the Imām ’s actions.
Both Imām al-Bāqir AS and Ibn al-Munkadir are described in Islamic literature as pious and ascetic scholars engaged in promulgating Hadith and Islamic knowledge. It is difficult to classify either of them as fully belonging to the circle of piety-minded opposition, and their active political resistance against the Umayyads remains similarly unclear. Nonetheless, both were products of a social environment in which opposition to Umayyad luxury often manifested in ascetic lifestyles, especially among the Medinan elite. Within this context, Ibn al-Munkadir’s remark becomes more understandable. He may have expected the Imām to follow this ascetic model, not completely renouncing worldly affairs, but to show some detachment from them. Seeing the Imām AS return from labour on a sweltering summer day, he may have perceived the activity as excessive worldly toil, something he did not expect from a man of such stature.
Imām’s response
Following this contextualisation of Ibn al-Munkadir’s remark, one can turn to the Imām ’s response, which not only clarified the matter but also compelled Ibn al-Munkadir to concede to his authority. The Imām explained that his labour was, in fact, an act of obedience and devotion to Allah. Even within the framework of piety-minded opposition, this response is meaningful, for by engaging in such work, the Imām distanced himself from the entitled classes who considered such tasks beneath them. In doing so, he implicitly taught Ibn al-Munkadir that no form of labour is elitist or exclusive and that the principles of Islam apply equally to both nobility and commoners.
Another narration in the same chapter of Ibtighāʾ al-Rizq in Kitāb Mukhtasar al-Athār adds a further dimension to the Imām’s actions. It is reported that a devotee once said to the Imām al-ṢādiqAS: ‘O beloved descendant of the Messenger of Allah, I have abandoned my business as I await your ẓuhūr and the manifestation of your authority.’ The Imām AS responded by guiding him: You should not act in this way. Instead, open your door to customers, lay out your wares, and seek sustenance from Allah, for this is more beneficial to you than what you are doing now. If you cease seeking sustenance, your wealth will diminish, and your resources will be depleted. It is therefore incumbent upon you to strive for your livelihood.’
Taken together, Imām al-Bāqir’s personal example of labour and Imām al-Ṣādiq’s counsel to his followers underscore the same principle: seeking sustenance is not opposed to piety, nor is it a distraction from awaiting ẓuhūr. Instead, in the context of satr, it is an essential contribution towards the Imām ’s mission. By binding the act of seeking sustenance to prepare for ẓuhūr, Imām AS redefined worldly labour as a form of religious devotion and readiness.
Al-Dāʿī al-Ajal al-Fāṭimī Syedna Aali Qadr Mufaddal Saifuddin TUS, while counselling Mumineen on commercial affairs and trade practices, has regularly emphasised adopting a higher vision for seeking livelihood. He explained that in their belief and intent, Mumineen should seek expansive conceptual horizons by recognising that their engagement in trade is not merely a mundane activity but a form of worship and a means of service to all humankind. A livelihood pursued with such an orientation brings honour both in this world and in the hereafter. This paradigm shift, which Syedna al-Dāʿī al-Ajal al-Fāṭimī seeks to cultivate, resonates with the response of Imām al-Bāqir AS to Ibn al-Munkadir. The Imām clarified that striving in trade should not be shunned or regarded as inherently blameworthy, but rather understood as an act of devotion, one that enriched his own pious life.
Conclusion
The brief yet profoundly illuminating encounter between Imām al-Bāqir AS and Ibn al-Munkadir, preserved in the Fāṭimid corpus, serves as a reminder that worldly aspirations, undertaken with the right intent and through permissible means, transform into acts of devotion. Moreover, situating Ibn al-Munkadir within his social and genealogical background highlights the gravity of this seemingly simple encounter. Such contextualisation underscores why heritage must be studied not as isolated narration but as part of a broader network of meanings that reveal multiple layers of Islamic history. Against this backdrop, Ibn al-Munkadir’s Qurashī identity, his invocation of elite ideals, and Imām al-Bāqir’s response, which embodied a more inclusive vision of Islamic norms, show how meaning extends beyond the textual lines. Moving beyond the text in this way allows one to discern subtle connections that improve one’s engagement with the Islamic tradition.
References
1 The same account also appears in Kitāb al-Manāqib wa-l-Mathālib and Kitāb Muntaẓaʿ al-Akhbār, vol. 1. Since the narration is essentially the same, the present focus is only on Kitāb Sharḥ al-Akhbār and ʿUyūn al-Akhbār.
2 Shams al-Dīn Muḥammad b. Aḥmad b. ʿUthmān al-Dhahabī, Siyar Aʿlām al-Nubalāʾ, vol. 5, ed. Shuʿayb al-Arnaʾūṭ (Beirut: al-Risālah Publishing House, 1996), 353–61.
3 al-Mufīd, Muḥammad b. Muḥammad b. al-Nuʿmān, al-Irshād fī Maʿrifat Ḥujaj Allāh ʿalā al-ʿIbād, vol. 2 (Beirut: Muʾassasat Āl al-Bayt, 2008), 161.
4 al-Dhahabī, Siyar Aʿlām al-Nubalāʾ, 5: 358.
5 Abū Nuʿaym al-Iṣfahānī, Ḥilyat al-Awliyāʾ wa-Ṭabaqāt al-Aṣfiyāʾ, vol. 2, ed. Sāmī Anwar Jāhīn (Cairo: Dār al-Ḥayth, 2009), 430.
6 Both al-Dhahabī and Abū Nuʿaym relate an account of how a man entrusted 500 dinars to Ibn al-Munkadir. As fate would have it, Ibn al-Munkadir was compelled to spend this trust (amānah). When the owner returned seeking his money, Ibn al-Munkadir supplicated earnestly to Allah, beseeching Him not to humiliate him. Both Abū Nuʿaym and al-Dhahabī record that he miraculously found the exact amount near him and was, thus, able to return the amānah. However, a different narration from al-Zubayr ibn Bakkār provides a more rational and plausible version of these events. According to this account, a certain ʿĀmir from the Quraysh tribe overhears Ibn al-Munkadir praying and discreetly leaves the required amount in a place where Ibn al-Munkadir would find it. After Ibn al-Munkadir discovers and uses the money to fulfil his obligation, ʿĀmir then informs him of his deed to prevent him from harbouring any false beliefs about the miraculous source of the money. This latter narration offers a rational explanation for what was otherwise recorded as one of Ibn al-Munkadir’s karāmāt.
Al-Zubayr b. Bakkār, Jamharat Nasab Quraysh wa-Akhbārahā, vol. 1, ed. D. ʿAbbās Hānī (Beirut: Dār al-Kutub al-ʿIlmiyya, 2010), 174.
7 al-Dhahabī, Siyar Aʿlām al-Nubalāʾ, 5: 358.
8 Ibid., 359.
9 Ibid., 355.
10 G. R. Hawting, The First Dynasty of Islam: The Umayyad Caliphate AD 661–750, 2nd ed. (London and New York: Routledge, 2000), 78.
11 Andrew Marsham, The Umayyad Empire (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2024), 93.
12 Jurjī Zaydān, Umayyads and ʿAbbāsids, trans. D. S. Margoliouth (Leiden: Brill, 1907), 68.
13 Hawting, The First Dynasty of Islam, 36.
14 Shawqī Ḍayf, Tārīkh al-Adab al-ʿArabī, vol. 2, al-ʿAṣr al-Islāmī (Cairo: Dār al-Maʿārif, 1960), 139.
15 Marshall G. S. Hodgson, The Venture of Islam: Conscience and History in a World Civilization, vol. 1, The Classical Age of Islam (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1974), 247–251.
